How Hollywood and Campus Justice Are Failing College Students
Sexual assault on America鈥檚 college campuses has been front page news lately, including a Rolling Stone about an alleged rape at the fraternity house on the University of Virginia鈥檚 campus in 2012. Although聽Rolling Stone has since acknowledged and apologized for possible errors in the story, it doesn鈥檛 change the fact that horrific acts of rape and sexual assault are happening鈥攁nd that college campuses are failing to deal appropriately with victims and cases that come to them. Students who have been assaulted by other college-aged men often still struggle to find any semblance of justice in the on-campus adjudication of their cases. Institutions frequently promote a culture of silence instead of protecting victims and expelling those who commit sexual assault. So in light of this national conversation, it鈥檚 hard not to wonder what鈥檚 feeding that 鈥渃ampus culture.鈥
Media depictions of American campus culture typically center on drug and alcohol use and abuse, academic apathy, and acts of sexual violence, often (or usually) against women. Kevin Carey, director of 国产视频鈥檚 Education Policy Program, observed this in a recent EdCentral on the dangers of the movie Animal House, saying:
Animal聽House聽and its brethren have taught millions of students how to think about college: Professors are fools, women are objects, and administrators are evil incarnate. Drink as much as you want and nothing bad will happen.
It may be聽easy for me, as a student myself, to say that frat-boy media programming that is targeted at our age group鈥攖hink National Lampoon鈥檚 Van Wilder and the Harold & Kumar series鈥攑erpetuates this culture, but scientific research also supports the claim. by Louise Wasylkiw and Michael Currie found that university students who viewed a clip of a 鈥渦niversity comedy film鈥 like Animal House had a more positive attitude towards substance abuse than students who watched an unrelated film, like Planet Earth. The researchers also believed that if students viewed more of these movies over time, the impact on their attitude would be more lasting and harder to change. As Carey said in his post, the litany of such films has only grown longer over the last few years鈥攕o that media narrative is long from disappearing.
But it鈥檚 not just Hollywood that is failing college students and victims of sexual violence alike. The way colleges address these issues also allows this campus culture to thrive. For starters, colleges have been for the investigation and administration of on-campus trials after reports of sexual violence. And those investigations are often flawed, led by people who are not law-enforcement officials and are not trained to conduct these types of investigations. Punishments meted out by colleges are often a mild reprimand for a serious crime. According to Yale Law professor Jed Rubenfeld in The New York Times, 鈥渃ollege punishments 鈥 sensitivity training, a one-semester suspension 鈥 are slaps on the wrist.鈥 This practice of light punishment for serious crimes also held true at Miami University. The Columbus Dispatch that the university punished a male student who assaulted one woman (and stole another鈥檚 pizza) by placing him on probation and forcing him to write an essay. Off campus, under , that student could have been imprisoned from six months to six years for the assault alone if convicted.
Congress passed the Clery Act to tighten requirements for universities to report incidents of sexual assault and other safety issues on their campuses to their students and to the federal government. But there is to suggest that crimes like sexual violence have decreased as a result. Even a White House found to be in violation of federal requirements so that they better respond to campus assaults has seen . To make impactful change, then, what really needs to happen is a culture shift in the media, and in the campus adjudication system.
To make impactful change, what really needs to happen is a culture shift in the media, and in the campus adjudication system.
Initiatives like from the White House are a step in the right direction. That campaign goes directly to the source鈥攖he students鈥攁nd engages with them alongside established to develop best practices for dealing with sexual violence on college campuses. The bystander intervention program, which was at my university, also engages with students to educate them about the role they can play in preventing crimes like rape.
Although compliance investigations are a good start, dealing with the problem of sexual violence on campus requires a two-step approach. Policymakers聽should consider whether it鈥檚 appropriate for campuses to be adjudicating criminal cases at all. And students need to be educated and held accountable for crimes that affect their entire community. Initiatives like 鈥淚t鈥檚 on Us鈥 illustrate that problems of rape and sexual violence are embedded on campuses across the country鈥攁nd send students the powerful message that they, too, have a role to play in preventing their all-too-frequent occurrence.