国产视频

In Short

The Texas “Justice Gap”

The Texas

A large number of Texans 鈥斕齧ostly middle class 鈥 fall into a “justice gap” where they aren’t poor enough to receive free legal aid provided to indigents but can’t afford basic legal services on their own, according to Nathan Hecht, chief justice of the Texas Supreme Court.听

But how many remains unknown, making the issue hard to address.听

鈥淭hese are not the very poor, these are people who are more middle income folks 鈥 and how many of them are there? It鈥檚 very difficult to tell,鈥 Hecht said last Monday. 鈥淏y any estimate, it鈥檚 a large number.鈥澨

Identifying Texans who can鈥檛 afford effective legal representation for civil matters 鈥 and suggesting effective ways to help 鈥 are the charges for a new commission the state’s highest civil court launched last Monday. The 18-member听Texas Commission to Expand Civil Legal Services, led by former Chief Justice Wallace Jefferson, will spend the next year gathering data and coming up with recommendations to be presented in November 2016.听

鈥淥ne of the most famous phrases in American law is liberty and justice for all 鈥 it is part of our culture, it is part of our custom, it is part of the fabric of our democracy,鈥 Jefferson said. 鈥淥ne of the biggest challenges today is to make that phrase a promise and to make that promise a reality.鈥澨

Jefferson, who served on the Texas Supreme Court from 2001 to 2013, said commission members will need to get creative in their problem-solving techniques. One idea, he offered as an example, would be setting people up with an annual 鈥渓egal check-up鈥 of the sort that happens in a doctor鈥檚 office.听

鈥淥nce a year, or periodically, you could come in and talk to a lawyer, maybe a lawyer that鈥檚 represented you in the past, and that lawyer might ask 鈥斕楧o you have elderly parents? What鈥檚 happening with them? Has there been a change in your life circumstances? Have you gotten married or divorced?鈥櫶

鈥淨uestions like this give rise to other questions, and people don鈥檛 even realize they have legal needs,鈥 Jefferson added. This kind of proactive check-in could be especially beneficial for veterans, he said, who don鈥檛 receive benefits they are due for any number of reasons.听

鈥淲e will look at veterans, Texas veterans, who come to the courts to secure benefits that our country owes them 鈥斕齜ut which have been too slow in coming in,鈥 he said.听

The language Jefferson used to frame the commission’s goals closely echoed an argument he made in front of Hecht and the court earlier this year.听

In September, Jefferson served as lead attorney in a case centering on indigent petitions, also known as pauper petitions. In that case, Jefferson represented six poor plaintiffs, all pursuing divorces, who were charged administrative court fees by the Tarrant County clerk鈥檚 office.听

During oral argument, Jefferson said plaintiffs鈥 access to the justice system, a 鈥渉allmark of justice,鈥 should not be contingent on their ability to pay those fees. The court has not yet ruled in the case.听

The commission will examine Texans鈥 access to both the state and federal court systems, which often take cues from each other when it comes to civil legal procedure, according to U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal, from Houston. Rosenthal said the issues the commission will grapple with are especially visible on the federal level.听

鈥淗alf of the litigants in our federal courts, roughly, represent themselves 鈥斕齝ivil litigants,鈥 Rosenthal said. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 a huge number.鈥澨

Jefferson said even lawyers often fall into the justice gap.听

鈥淭oday, even most lawyers cannot afford to retain another lawyer to represent them in civil legal disputes,鈥 Jefferson said. 鈥淭his is a crisis for the legal profession and for our state.鈥澨

This article originally appeared in .

More 国产视频 the Authors

Jordan Rudner
The Texas “Justice Gap”