The (Eastern) German
On November 9, 1989, thirty-five-year-old Angela Merkel with a friend, just as they did every Thursday. But outside, the city was electric: The Berlin Wall had fallen, and Eastern Germans were rushing to freely cross into West Berlin for the first time in 28 years.
The next morning, Merkel, then a quantum chemist, went to work as usual. Sixteen years later, however鈥攄espite having no background in politics prior to 1989鈥擬erkel would become the first eastern German chancellor.
When the Berlin Wall fell, it would have been unimaginable for an eastern German to lead a reunited Germany. Now, on the thirtieth anniversary of that night, Merkel has become one of the country鈥檚 longest standing chancellors. But she鈥檚 still one of very few eastern Germans to rise to the political elite鈥攁nd as such, leaves behind a complicated legacy of her own chancellorship and of the limited political power eastern Germans hold today.
On the East German legislature voted to adopt the federal German constitution, replacing the former authoritarian state鈥檚 centrally-planned elections and economy with western German liberal democracy and capitalism. Largely unfamiliar with these new structures, eastern Germans entered reunification at a disadvantage. Westerners considered many Easterners for positions in the new political system, and both eastern and western Germans were skeptical of anyone . As a result, western Germans held a disproportionate majority of state and federal positions during reunification鈥攕etting a precedent of western-led leadership that continues today.
As of 2016, only came from the East鈥攁lthough make up 17 percent of the national population and 87 percent within eastern states. , eastern Germans held just 70 percent of senior government positions and 13.3 percent of judgeships in top state courts in 2016. Today, only two members of Merkel鈥檚 sixteen-person cabinet lived under the GDR, including her.
Thus, Angela Merkel鈥檚 ascendance to chancellor in 2005 was a historic achievement for eastern Germans. The question then was how this would shape her governing.
Merkel鈥檚 approach to politics might suggest an eastern German-influenced : Her decision-making process is characterized by careful study and 鈥渢iny steps,鈥 and she鈥檚 known for holding firm opinions once she鈥檚 made them鈥攚hile keeping her thoughts essentially opaque. Many observers of Merkel have theorized that this scrupulousness is perhaps unsurprising for someone who grew up under a repressive government鈥攐ne with , , and .
But in her policies, Merkel has proven to be more of an internationally-focused chancellor than an eastern-focused one. Over the last fourteen years, Merkel has become the European Union鈥檚 navigating challenges such as Russian aggression towards Ukraine, the global recession, and the Greek bailout. By 2017, were whether she stood not just as the German chancellor, but as the 鈥渓eader of the free world.鈥
According to Irish Times journalist Derek Scally, many of her eastern constituents were with this leadership. But that changed in 2015, when fled . Merkel鈥檚 decision to welcome refugees to Germany left some of her eastern German constituents feeling deeply betrayed: While the German government has invested over two trillion euros in the East since reunification (versus just on migrant resettlement), many eastern Germans believe the government has reneged on its promise of an eastern economic miracle in favor of migrant interests.
For some, this reaction stems from xenophobic, racist, anti-immigrant nationalism. For others, it鈥檚 rooted in long-standing economic frustration. Twenty-nine years after the collapse of the GDR鈥檚 centrally-planned economy, eastern Germany鈥檚 economy still lags behind that of Western states. Today, the average eastern income is about , and per 2015 data, were above the national average. Merkel鈥檚 decision to shift Germany away from coal energy, which will eliminate , has not reassured voters.
Earlier this year, Merkel acknowledged she hadn鈥檛 always prioritized eastern German concerns, bluntly stating that she couldn鈥檛 while handling both the 2008 financial crisis and the 2015 refugee crisis. 鈥淢y day has only 24 hours,鈥 she said. This week, that she 鈥淸has] to serve all people in Germany.鈥 To her, 鈥渢he assumption that [she] should primarily deal with the concerns of the east Germans is, therefore, wrong.鈥
Merkel, then, can鈥檛 be accused of favoring the East as chancellor鈥攁nd her political pragmatism reflects a general trend among successful eastern German politicians today. During reunification, eastern German politicians and were rewarded for prioritizing national and European issues over regional ones. They were also explicitly cautioned against discussing the regional divide鈥攊n 2000, the minister president asked the Christian Democratic Party (CDU) speaker for Eastern parliamentary representatives .鈥
According to , Merkel had 鈥渘o political agenda at all鈥 when she first entered German politics, adopting the CDU platform not out of ideological passion, but by studying the manual. She鈥檚 also been her own eastern background, and with good reason: When she first became CDU chairwoman in 2004, some in her party suspected her of trying to in reunited Germany. In other words, notes Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung political correspondent Karl Feldmeyer, Merkel has a
In short, Merkel has not always prioritized eastern German interests鈥攁nd according to , she also hasn鈥檛 鈥淸prioritized] the integration of [other] eastern elites.鈥 To Yoder, Merkel鈥檚 success is just another sign that reunification took place 鈥渁ccording to western norms and experiences, with little actual synthesis or integration.鈥
Over time, the political distance practiced by Merkel and other eastern German politicians has yielded observable democratic consequences. As of 2010, there was a between the ideologies and approaches to governance held by eastern German constituents and those favored by their eastern representatives. This is, of course, natural in every democracy鈥攂ut the gap was nevertheless smaller between western German politicians and their voters.
This disconnect, then, may have provided a crucial opportunity for a party like the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD). The AfD, which is much more successful in eastern states, recently won huge gains in Brandenburg, Saxony, and Thuringia state elections with a campaign that鈥攙ia their trademark xenophobic rhetoric鈥攑romised the reunification outcomes that politicians like Merkel have supposedly failed to deliver.
Last year, Merkel joked about her to then-chancellor Helmut Kohl鈥檚 鈥渦nity cabinet鈥 in 1990. 鈥淚 was still relatively young for politics 鈥 came from the East, and was a woman, so I ticked three [quota] boxes,鈥 she said.
In many ways, her long political career since then has been an exercise in proving herself an individual, not someone who simply fulfills a quota. And, for better or worse, she has done just that.